Indiana – A 297-vote lead put Chris Garten on the verge of leading the Indiana Senate. A judge’s order put his oath of office on hold.
The pause lasted less than a day. Indiana’s Supreme Court cleared Garten to take office Tuesday, but the questions that brought his election to court remain unresolved.
Scott County Circuit Court Judge Jason Mount issued a temporary restraining order Monday, Nov. 16, barring the Republican senator from taking the oath for another four-year term or being seated for District 45.
Democrats had requested the order before Tuesday’s Organization Day, when Senate Republicans planned to elevate Garten to president pro tem.

Credit: Sen. Chris Garten’s Office
Read also: The least popular Indiana governor in decades wants four more years
Mount’s order also stopped the Clark County Election Board and court clerk from certifying and transmitting county results for the Senate race. It covered the Clark County auditor’s race as well. A hearing on the Democrats’ request for a preliminary injunction was scheduled for Wednesday afternoon in Jeffersonville.
The fight began at Jeffersonville High School, where voters from four precincts cast ballots on Election Day. A ballot scanner malfunctioned and was replaced. Democrats say the Clark County Election Board, whose members are two Republicans and one Democrat, did not do enough to check whether every vote was counted.
Their court filing points to figures they say need to be reconciled. A machine results tape shows 1,640 ballots. According to the filing, 474 ballots were cast before the machine was replaced, while only 333 voters had signed in by 11:08 a.m.
Poll pad records also show more than 100 sign-ins after 7 p.m., an hour after polls closed. Those figures form the basis of the challenge; they do not, by themselves, establish that votes went uncounted.
Reported District 45 totals show Garten with 21,817 votes and Democrat Nick Marshall with 21,520, a difference of 297 votes, or roughly two-thirds of a percentage point. The district covers Clark County and part of Floyd County.
Clark County Democratic Chair Miguel Hampton, state Democratic Chair Karen Tallian and Ninth Congressional District party Chair Adam Dickey said the election board had left them “no other option but to resolve this issue in the courts.” They argued that Garten should not begin a new term before the Indiana Recount Commission could review the results.
Garten had called the Democrats’ claims “political theater” last week and said he expected his victory to stand. After the order, his attorneys appealed to the Indiana Supreme Court, arguing that a court could not decide who may appear before the Senate to take an oath.
On Tuesday, the justices unanimously lifted the part of Mount’s order blocking Garten from taking office, citing the state constitution’s provision that each legislative chamber judges the elections of its own members. The restriction on certifying the Clark County results remained. Garten was sworn in and chosen as president pro tem. He also said he had directed his attorneys to seek a recount.
The oath settled who would lead the chamber for now. The disputed vote count still faces review.